The Conversation
30 Nov 2021, 00:09 GMT+10
U.S. President Joe Biden's Build Back Better Act shows that American protectionism existed before and continues past the Donald Trump administration. Canada must finally learn from this hallmark of American politics and calibrate its trade policy to have a stronger industrial focus.
Under the proposed bill, consumers of electric vehicles can receive US$12,500 in tax credits. But to receive the full rebate, the vehicle must be produced by American manufacturers.
The act, not yet approved by the Senate, serves as a response to both economic and environmental crises. It aims to restore the American auto industry while addressing climate change.
Canada's international trade minister, Mary Ng, says in a letter to congressional leaders that the bill is discriminatory and will cause "irreparable harm" to both Canadian and American auto sectors. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said he also expressed concern about the rebates and their impact on continental trade in his recent Oval Office meeting with Biden.
Despite their frustration, Canadian policy-makers shouldn't be surprised. The proposed legislation is among a string of protectionist measures pushed by several administrations.
The Barack Obama administration supported Buy American provisions in the wake of the 2008 economic recession. Canadian policy-makers complained at the time that the provisions were discriminatory, and they were ultimately watered down.
The Trump administration was especially protectionist. It applied tariffs broadly, including on Canadian steel and aluminium twice. By 2019, the United States was leading the world with more sanctions than at any other period in its history.
Biden signalled his support for America-first provisions during his presidential campaign. The Democratic platform included references to restoring auto sector jobs and increasing electric vehicle sales.
In April 2021, the Biden administration opened a Made in America Office and directed agencies to increase the amount of American content in their purchases.
More broadly, Americans have long offered significant subsidies to its agricultural sector.
The trend line in American trade policy is clear. Protectionism is back on table in significant ways.
Scholars have argued that crises demand exceptional state intervention to ensure a return to stability. The Biden administration must lead on the environment, the economy, health and social justice while staying politically viable. These pressures leave Biden with little choice.
Ng has already signalled Canada's intention to fight the American EV rebates. Beyond the Canadian delegation's recent lobbying visit to Washington, D.C., Ng has argued that the rebates are "inconsistent" with agreements like the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement, known as CUSMA.
Setting aside the potential success of a challenge, Canada has other and better options.
The Canadian government has often been a driver of industry. Especially before the 1980s, Ottawa used federal subsidies, Crown corporations and strategic infrastructure developments to support industry.
Though these tools continue, new economic thinking has tended to push policy-makers away from their use. Instead, the preference has been to let the markets do the work.
But federal supports continue as a form of regional development. Aerospace, dairy, cod fishing, forestry and petroleum industries each have regional dynamics that help motivate government support.
While not all state inventions are the same as the consumer EV rebates in Biden's Build Back Better legislation, their purposes are similar. Pro-industry policies help fuel economic growth and social cohesion and can assist governments in achieving other political goals, like net-zero emissions.
Canadian governments have the tools on hand to insulate domestic industries from significant market changes.
These tools are actively used in some areas. The government continues to defend dairy supply management, for example, as critical to our prosperity.
Canadian governments also use tax credits to promote consumption. Without limiting them to vehicles built in Canada, both federal and provincial governments offer electric vehicle subsidies. These subsidies have a similar dollar value to the current American proposal.
There may be reason to believe this is not a sustainable practice. But Canada has few other options.
It appears Canadian lawmakers are still hoping the Americans will exempt Canada from Build Back Better. Ontario's Conservative government under Doug Ford is resisting electric vehicle rebates, while the Trudeau government continues to appeal to Washington to exclude Canada from the measures.
But even if Canada is successful in stopping the proposed EV rebates, American protectionism is here to stay.
While embracing protectionism is not to Canada's advantage, holding out for exemptions isn't good policy. Instead, Canada needs to accept the reality of global trading conditions.
Certainly, there are international responses for Canada. Canada should reflect on its Inclusive Trade Agenda more. This review should include a reconsideration of the value of global trade deals over bilateral agreements.
But Canada should also look inward. Targeted supports to Canadian industries will be needed to weather this protectionist storm.
Author: Noah Fry - PhD Student, Political Science, McMaster University
Get a daily dose of Pittsburgh Star news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Pittsburgh Star.
More InformationWASHINGTON, D.C.: Travelers at U.S. airports will no longer need to remove their shoes during security screenings, Department of Homeland...
(Photo credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images) Manny Machado homered and the San Diego Padres' bullpen tossed 4 1/3 scoreless innings to...
(Photo credit: Ken Blaze-Imagn Images) Casey Mize got some big news before his final start prior to the All-Star break. The Detroit...
(Photo credit: Matt Blewett-Imagn Images) Trevor Larnach belted a two-run home run and the Minnesota Twins held on for a 2-1 win...
(Photo credit: Jeff Curry-Imagn Images) The St. Louis Cardinals removed star third baseman Nolan Arenado from their game against...
(Photo credit: John Jones-Imagn Images) After their meeting in the U.S. Open Cup was postponed due to severe weather, the Philadelphia...
ATLANTA, Georgia: The United States is facing its worst measles outbreak in more than three decades, with 1,288 confirmed cases so...
In the past month alone, 23 Israeli soldiers have been killed in Gaza—three more than the number of remaining living hostages held...
LONDON, U.K.: At least 13 people are believed to have taken their own lives as a result of the U.K.'s Post Office scandal, in which...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: Travelers at U.S. airports will no longer need to remove their shoes during security screenings, Department of Homeland...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: An elaborate impersonation scheme involving artificial intelligence targeted senior U.S. and foreign officials in...
SLUBICE, Poland: Poland reinstated border controls with Germany and Lithuania on July 7, following Germany's earlier reintroduction...