The Man Who Fell to Earth [DVD]
Director : Nicolas Roeg
Screenplay : Paul Mayersberg (based on the novel by Walter Tevis)
MPAA Rating : NR
Year of Release : 1976
Stars : David Bowie (Thomas Jerome Newton), Rip Torn (Nathan Bryce), Candy Clark (Mary-Lou), Buck Henry (Oliver Farnsworth), Bernie Casey (Peters), Jackson D. Kane (Professor Canutti), Rick Riccardo (Trevor), Tony Mascia (Arthur)
Nicolas Roeg, one of the great “mad poets” to emerge from British cinema, began his career as a cinematographer, and it shows in his films, which are unusually alive and charged with friction, danger, eroticism, and lyrical moments of such beauty that they seem almost fluid. He has a gift for making the mundane seem extraordinary, or at least weird, which is why he was so uniquely equipped to tackle The Man Who Fell to Earth, a science fiction parable with virtually no science or special effects or spacescapes or any of the other imagery we have come to associate with the genre.
The Man Who Fell to Earth is simultaneously one of Roeg’s best films and one of his worst, which is not an impossible contradiction in his realm. It is plugged directly into Roeg’s visual gifts and mystical sensibilities, which he had already displayed to great effect in the beautiful, tragic children’s story Walkabout (1971) and the psychic horror thriller Don’t Look Now (1973). But, The Man Who Fell to Earth also gets muddled in Roeg’s tendency to elevate imagery over narrative and character, to the point that it becomes all but incomprehensible by the final reel. This is not necessarily a bad thing, except to those classical Hollywood purists who feel that story is the central essence of filmmaking; but, at the same time, it is arguably a hindrance to the film’s overriding political themes, which get as blurred and washed out as the multiple storylines.
Roeg made the brilliant casting choice of using pop icon David Bowie, who at the time had just come off his gender-bending Ziggy Stardust tour and was at the height of his ’70s superstardom, to play the film’s titular alien. Especially in his younger years, Bowie already had a slightly otherworldly quality, and his waxy, androgynous beauty gives the constant illusion that he is something else playing behind a mask. His lithe body and gentle face suggest a kind of innocence, as if he is not yet fully formed, which is central to the film’s message about the nature of corruption.
Bowie’s alien has come to earth in search of water to save his dying planet, which we see if brief, dusty flashbacks. He takes the name Thomas Jerome Newton, each part of which is borrowed from a famous scientist/inventor (Thomas Edison, Jerome Lemelson, and Sir Isaac Newton), which is apt because he makes his fortune on earth by controlling nine basic patents that he brought with him, one of which is a form of self-developing film. These patents allow him to build an enormous tech corporation, the profits of which he plans to use to build a spaceship, ostensibly to return him to his home planet, although that is just supposition since it’s never made entirely clear.
While on earth, Newton interacts with several recurring characters, each of whom represents some form of human fallibility that is unfortunately passed on to Newton, who becomes so corrupted by their influence that his mission is in constant jeopardy. When he first arrives, he contacts a patent attorney named Oliver Farnsworth (Buck Henry), whose basic greediness represents the rotten core on which American industry is constructed. Newton also hires a scientist named Nathan Bryce (Rip Torn), whose days as a lecherous college professor were spent chasing his female students. Finally, Newton meets Mary-Lou (Candy Clark), a sweet, simply maid at a hotel who will eventually become his lover, but whose neediness and lack of identity interject constant cloudiness into Newton’s life and sense of purpose. She is also alcoholic who introduces Newton to the pleasures of gin and vodka, and the physical dependence he develops to alcohol proves to be his true undoing.
The underlying message that ties all these characters and their weaknesses together is the debilitating dangers of addiction--to money, to sex, to drugs, to power. There is no solace to be found in any of these things: The money is ultimately meaningless, sex is depicted as violent and depraved (at one point even involving a pistol), alcohol merely numbs and confuses, and the consolation of power only incites the wrath of those with even more power, in this case a shady government agency that eventually captures Newton and kills Farnsworth because their corporation had become too threatening. Even love doesn’t seem to hold any sense of redemption, as it fails under challenge and eventually leads to betrayal. In some way or other, every human in the film betrays Newton, which is quite possibly the one thing he never could have anticipated.
In the sense that Newton is portrayed as innocence corrupted, The Man Who Fell to Earth plays like a modern fairy tale. At one point, Mary-Lou asks Newton if he hates her, and he says no, that hate is an impossibility for him. Innocence, in this sense, is Edenic innocence--the inability to distinguish between good and evil. Newton remains an enigmatic character because he doesn’t carry with him all the human traits that we latch onto, both positive and negative. He is something of a blank slate, and when he does reveal emotion, it is because it has been rubbed off on him by others. The only emotion he displays that feels in some way organic to his character is fear.
Roeg and his screenwriter Paul Mayersberg, who adapted a 1963 novel by Walter Tevis (best known for writing The Hustler), are primarily interested in the idea of otherness and what happens when an alien body is subjected to the influences of modern civilization. The story covers several decades, and the narrative moves in fits and jumps, often leaping ahead many years with a single cut, which leaves the viewer frequently disoriented and grasping for connection, much like Newton himself. The film’s jagged, sometimes confusing nonlinear structure and its tendency to make American iconography (from skyscrapers to Western landscapes) slightly otherworldly firmly plants us in Newton’s shoes, showing us the familiar through alien(ated) eyes.
Critics were not terribly kind to The Man Who Fell to Earth when it premiered in 1976, either in England or in the U.S. American critics were at a distinct disadvantage since the U.S. distributor inanely chopped 20 minutes out of the film, making it even more incoherent and robbing it of some of its crucial thematic meaning. But, even with those 20 minutes restored, the film’s narrative confusion and heavy symbolism make for a difficult viewing experience, and many critics simply didn’t want to try to wrap their minds around Roeg’s enigmatic imagery. John Simon, never one to mince words, wrote disparagingly, “it is, like all Roeg’s films, the blowing up of something simple or simple-minded to arrogantly bloated dimensions and purporting to be chock-full of hermetic truths merely awaiting their interpreters.”
In a sense, Simon is right, although I would argue that there is nothing simple or simple-minded about the themes in The Man Who Fell to Earth. In fact, like the best of science fiction, it uses one of the genre’s most fundamental narratives (the alien visitor) to explore larger issues, in this case the nature of human corruption. Although not all the details fall squarely into place and the narrative bits and pieces don’t entirely add up, Roeg is certainly successful in painting a sometimes beautiful, frequently painful, but always intriguing cinematic portrait of innocence corrupted. In writing about Jean-Luc Godard’s Masculin féminin in 1965, the great critic Pauline Kael noted quite rightly “you don’t need to understand every detail in order to experience the beauty of the work as it’s going on.” The exact same could be said for The Man Who Fell to Earth.
|The Man Who Fell to Earth Director-Approved Criterion Collection Two-Disc DVD Set|
|Audio||English Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo|
|Distributor||The Criterion Collection|
|Release Date||September 27, 2005|
|The Man Who Fell to Earth has been widely available on DVD, first in a less-than-exceptional bare-bones release by Fox-Lorber and then a much improved special edition by Anchor Bay in 2003. For its third DVD incarnation, Criterion has upped the stakes with an even better high-definition anamorphic transfer, this one taken from an interpositive struck from the original camera negative and supervised by Nicolas Roeg. The result is an excellent image, with great clarity and sharpness. The opening shots appear uneven, with some shots being quite grainy, but this is simply the result of intercutting stock footage. The overall look of the film varies from crisp and intense, to sometimes soft and surreal, which is the nature of Roeg’s vision. Digital restoration has also removed virtually all signs of age, leaving a nearly spotless image.|
|Audio purists will be glad that Criterion has included the film’s original stereo soundtrack, mastered from the 35mm magnetic print master. Those who like a lot of surround sound, however, will be disappointed that Criterion did not include the remixed Dolby Digital EX 5.1 and DTS ES 6.1 surround tracks included on the Anchor Bay special edition. Nevertheless, the soundtrack included here is more than adequate; Roeg’s eclectic mix of music and sound effects is highly effective, and audio restoration has ensured good clarity and lack of ambient hiss throughout.|
|While Anchor Bay’s 2003 release included a smattering of supplements, including a well-done making-of featurette, Criterion’s new edition stands head and shoulders above it in terms of supplementary material, starting with the audio commentary, originally recorded in 1992 for the Criterion laser disc. It features director Nicolas Roeg and actor David Bowie recorded together, as well as comments from actor Buck Henry recorded separately. Much like the film itself, the commentary is a big fractured, sometimes wandering off into odd territory, but is often extremely fascinating and illuminating (plus Bowie does a pretty hilarious Rip Torn impersonation). |
The second disc opens with several new video interviews. One is with screenwriter Paul Mayersberg, who discusses how he adapted Walter Tevis’ source novel and some of the ideas he and Roeg were trying to get at. A second video interview includes stars Candy Clark and Rip Torn (interviewed separately), who discuss working with Roeg and their thoughts on the film’s significance (Clark also discusses her deep discomfort with on-screen nudity, which means she must have been uncomfortable a lot). There are also a number of audio interviews, including one from 1984 with novelist Walter Tevis and a pair of interviews with costume designer May Routh and production designer Brian Eatwell. The rest of the disc is rounded out with a heavy collection of stills galleries: costume sketches, production and publicity photos, on-set photos, continuity photos, and international posters of Nicolas Roeg’s films. There is also a good collection of British, U.S., and international theatrical trailers. Lastly, like Criterion’s Short Cuts special edition, The Man Who Fell to Earth is packaged with a special reprint of Walter Tevis’ source novel.
While this is an excellent special edition all around, the one thing I found lacking was any supplementary material discussing the differences between the full director’s cut and the original U.S. theatrical cut, which was a crucial problem in the film’s U.S. reception. The Criterion laser disc edition from 1992 noted which chapters included material not in the U.S. theatrical cut and also had a featurette titled “X Marks the Spot” that examined the differences between the two versions. So, for those of you who, like me, own the laser disc, I would recommend holding on to it.
Copyright ©2005 James Kendrick
Thoughts? E-mail James Kendrick
All images copyright © The Criterion Collection